TOPIC 3: PROBLEMS OF MAKING A PEACE SETTLEMENT

THE VERSAILLES PEACE TREATY (1919)

Before Italy withdrew, there were four leaders i.e

AIMS OF THE VERSAILLES TREATY

  • To solve problems which had led to World war I and bring peace. o To form independent states from the Empires of Russia, Turkey and Germany. o To weaken Germany.

  • To form a world body to keep peace I the world. This was the League of Nations.
  • NB: On 28 June 1919, Germany was forced to sign. She accepted because: she was afraid of renewed war.

  • She was under a new government which wanted peace.

    THEIR IDEAS

    GEORGES CLEMENCEAU

  • Wanted a treaty to provide enough protection to France against future German attack.
    » He wanted Germany to pay for damages of war.
  • WOODROW WILSON

    » Wanted to form independent states and a world body to keep peace.

    LLOYD GEORGE

  • Wanted to balance his friends' ideas because the people who elected him wanted Germany to be punished (they shouted, "hang the Kaizer!)
  • On the other hand, he argued that any harsh punishment would store trouble for the future as Germany would be looking for revenge.
  • TERMS OF THE TREATY

    1. MILITARY LOSSES

  • Allied leaders should occupy the Rhineland (border between France and Germany) for some time,
  • A 50km belt on the Germany side of river Rhine was to be demilitarized.
  • Germany army was to be limited to 100,000 men, a small navy but no submarines and air forces.
  • 2. TERRITORIAL LOSSES

  • The saar basin (an important source of coal for Germany) was to be administered by the League of Nations for 15 years during which France was to look after the mines until a plebiscite (referendum) was held to decide its future.
  • All Germany colonies were to be mandated. African colonies were divided among France, Britain, Belgium and South Africa.
  • Alsace and Lorraine were to go back to France.
  • Port of Memmel in West Prussia was to be under international control to provide an outlet to the sea for Lithuania. In 1923, Lithuania took control of Memmel.
  • Danzig was declared a free city.
  • The anschluss (union) of Germany and Austria was forbidden.
  • Russia lost Lativia, Finland, Estonia and Lithuania which became independent, but also Bessarabia and some land to Poland.
  • 3. ECONOMIC LOSSES

    WILSON'S ROLE

  • He came up with 14 ideas which are also known as Wilson's 14 points. THE POINTS

    WHY THE GERMANS REJECTED THE TERMS OF THE VERSAILLES TREATY

  • They called the treaty a diktat by claiming that they had not been invited to the conference where they could have toned down some of the harsher terms.
  • They objected that wrong people had signed it. They felt that it should have been signed by admirals/generals who led Germany to war.
  • They claimed that they had been promised based on Wilson's 14 points yet the terms were not in accordance with that.
  • Germany grieved the loss of her territories in Africa thus being denied the right of national self-determination.
  • They resented the disarmament clause by asserting that 100,000 troops were not enough to keep law and order.
  • The rejected the war-guilt clause that put the entire blame for the outbreak of World war I on Germany. They argued that the period was too short to arrive at such a decision.
  • They also objected the reparations which they considered a humiliation; £6,600 million was far too high.
  • WHY IT IS PROPER TO CALL THE VERSAILLES TREAT A 'PEACE SETTLEMENT"

    WHY IT IS IMPROPER TO CALL THE VERSAILLES TREAT A 'PEACE SETTLEMENT"

  • Statesmen attended the conference wit different attitudes and interests.
  • Deliberations were not democratic; they were centred on the "Big Three."
  • War-guilt clause blamed Germany alone.
  • Reparations of £6,600 million pounds were too high for Germany.
  • Right of national self-determination did not apply to defeated and neutral powers.
  • Neutral and defeated powers were not represented at the meeting.
  • The period was too short to make all those decisions.
  • There was too much quarrelling among the Big Three.
  • Most terms were made to weaken Germany economically and politically.
  • Disarmament only applied to defeated powers.
  • Germany lost her territories in Africa.